KidzSearch Wiki

Moon landing conspiracy theories

Astronauts Buzz Aldrin and Neil Armstrong in NASA's training mockup of the Moon and lander module. Conspiracy theorists say that the films of the missions were made using sets similar to this training mockup.

The moon landing conspiracy theories (also known as moon landing hoax or Apollo hoax) are beliefs that men did not land on the Moon in 1969–1972 during the Apollo program and that NASA faked the information. Some conspiracy theorists believe the Skylab space station is also a hoax.[1](p. 162)[2]

This belief is considered by the scientific community and historians to be irrational. But on the internet, the debate can occur since it is easy for anyone to publish their ideas.[3] There are subcultures within the USA and cultures around the world that believe that the Moon landings were faked. This view is claimed to have been taught in Cuban schools and wherever else Cuban teachers are sent (Nicaragua, Angola).[4][5][6] It is also shared by the Taliban[7] and by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON).[8][9][10]

History

On 12 April 1961, the USSR sent the first man into space in Vostok 1, Yuri Gagarin.[11] Six weeks later, US President John Kennedy promised a manned Moon landing by 1969 to win the battle of systems and impress the world with technical superiority:

Finally, if we are to win the battle that is now going on around the world between freedom and tyranny, the dramatic achievements in space which occurred in recent weeks should have made clear to us all, as did the Sputnik in 1957, the impact of this adventure on the minds of men everywhere, who are attempting to make a determination of which road they should take. Full Text

Moon conspiracy theorists say that NASA had too many technical problems to meet the eight year deadline for going to the moon. But the USA could not afford to appear lose the race to the moon to the Soviet Union, and so the moon landings were faked.[12] In 2004, President George Bush gave not eight but sixteen years for a manned return to the Moon, even though the technologies for it should have already been developed forty years earlier.[13][14] In 2010, President Barack Obama canceled this plan, which seemed to the moon conspiracy theorists to be an admission that the USA still does not have the technology to go to the moon.[15]

Doubts about the authenticity of the Apollo Moon landings appeared first in December 1968 when Apollo 8 was launched.[16] The almost perfectly executed odyssey of Apollo 11 amazed many around the world, and some people doubted it was real.[17]

The first book on the subject ("Did man land on the Moon?") was issued in Texas by the mathematician James J. Cranny in 1970.[18]

NASA commented on some of the conspiracy theories in June 1977.[19] But in August 1997, their Director of Media Services (1998–2000) Brian Welch (1958–2000) said in an interview with Sky TV News:[20](p. 68)[21](48:13–48:46)[22]

“ This is thirty year old stuff... I don't understand why we should spend the time to... prove to people that we went to the Moon; in fact of matters we did go to the Moon. ”

When Fox TV aired Bruce Nash's film "Conspiracy theory: Did we land on the Moon?" in 2001, NASA released hoax theory rebuttal materials on their web and FTP sites.[23] They also wrote suggestions for science teachers on how to refute the hoax claims using the Lunar Sample Disk Kits.[19][24][25][26][27][28][29][30]

In 2002, NASA hired James Edward Oberg, to write a book intended to challenge those who claim the Apollo Moon landings were a hoax. Oberg was a former rocket scientist, MSNBC News space consultant and analyst and journalist, and, it was later discovered, a moon landing conspiracy theorist. But NASA soon cancelled the project, declining to give the reasons for this. NASA spokesman Bob Jacobs said criticism that NASA was displaying poor judgement and a lack of confidence in commissioning the book caused the agency to abort it.[31][32][33] For example, then NASA Administrator Sean O'Keefe said:[34]

“ The issue of trying to do a targeted response to this is just lending credibility to something that is, on its face, asinine. ”

In 2006, some of the recordings of the Apollo era were declared missing.[35] The question of what happened to the recordings was seen by conspiracy theorists as confirmation of their beliefs, and in 2009, NASA revealed that the tapes were erased.[36][37][38]

Claims

The arguments about the moon conspiracy theories are detailed and complex. Some of the major points and counterpoints are listed below.

Complexity

Moon conspiracy theorists think that NASA faked the Apollo mission with a secret program. According to James Longuski, the complexity of the conspiracy theory scenarios make them impossible. More than 400,000 people worked on the Apollo project for almost ten years, and 12 men who walked on the Moon returned to Earth to talk about their experiences. Hundreds of thousands of people would have had to keep the secret. Longuski says that it would have been a lot easier to actually land on the Moon than to create such a large conspiracy to fake it.[39][40]

Photography and videos

1. In some photos, the crosshairs are seemed to be partially covered by objects. Some conspiracy theorists suggest that the NASA composed the photographs by "cutting and pasting" objects over the background images.

  • Bright sunlight can wash-out thin lines over the white objects.[41]
 
An example of "partially covered" crosshair.

2. In some photos, the crosshairs are rotated.

 
An example of "rotated" crosshairs.
 
Original version of the photo (Photo ID: AS11-40-5869).

3. The letter "C" appears on some rocks. This is maybe a designation by the studio props.

  • The "C"-shaped objects are printing mistake and do not appear in the original film from the camera. It has been suggested that the "C" is a hair or other fiber.[43]
 
An example of "C" rock.
 
Original version of the photo (Photo ID: AS16-107-17446).

4. The book Moon Shot[44] contains a fake photo of Alan Shepard hitting a golf ball on the Moon with another astronaut.

  • It was used instead of the original photos, because the editors thought that the original photos would be too grainy for their book. The book publishers did not work for NASA.

Environment

1. The Apollo 16 crew could not have survived solar flares when they were on their way to the Moon.

  • No large solar flare occurred during the flight of Apollo 16. There were large solar flares in August 1972, after Apollo 16 returned to Earth and before the flight of Apollo 17.[45][46]

2. During the Apollo 15 mission, David Scott did an experiment by dropping a hammer and a falcon feather at the same time. Both hit the ground at the same time.

David Scott drops a hammer and a feather on the Moon.

Missing data

Blueprints and drawings of the machines used in the Apollo project are missing.[47][48] Some Apollo 11 tapes containing telemetry and high quality video of the first moonwalk are also missing. Moon landing conspiracy theorists believe that this is because they never existed, since the mission was faked.[49]

 
Original high-quality image from the missing tapes.

Dr. David Williams (NASA archivist at Goddard Space Flight Center) and Apollo 11 flight director Eugene F. Kranz acknowledged that some of the Apollo 11 tapes are missing. When the recordings were sent back to Earth to be shown on TV, they were converted to a different format which was lower quality.[50] Now the lower quality tapes are available, but the original high quality videos received in Australia are missing. Some pictures of the original high quality image are still available, and videos have been released from other missions too, like the Apollo Lunar Surface Experiments Package.[51]

Some people at NASA are looking for the tapes to help them plan for future missions. They believe the Apollo 11 tapes were sent for storage at the U.S. National Archives in 1970, but by 1984 all the Apollo 11 tapes had been returned to the Goddard Space Flight Center. The tapes may have been stored rather than re-used, and efforts to determine where they were stored are ongoing.[52] Goddard was storing 35,000 new tapes per year in 1967, even before the lunar landings.[53]

 
Apollo 16 Lunar Module

On November 1, 2006 Cosmos Magazine reported that 100 data tapes recorded in Australia during the Apollo 11 mission had been found in the basement of the Curtin University of Technology in Perth, Australia. One of the old tapes was sent to NASA for analysis.

On July 16, 2009, NASA said that it must have erased the original Apollo 11 Moon footage years ago so that it could reuse the tape. On December 22, 2009 NASA issued a final report on the tapes.[54] Senior engineer Dick Nafzger concluded that approximately 45 tapes of Apollo 11 video were erased and reused.[55] For the 40th anniversary of the Apollo moon landing, Lowry Digital of Burbank, California restored the low quality videos. Some pieces of the restored footage are available on the NASA website.[56]

Deaths of Apollo workers

Some conspiracy theorists say that some astronauts were killed as part of a cover up. In a television program about the conspiracy theory, Fox Entertainment Group listed 10 astronauts and 2 others who conspiracy theorists said were killed.

  • Theodore Freeman (plane crash, 1964)
  • Elliot See and Charles Bassett (T-38 accident, 1966)
  • Gus Grissom (Apollo 1 fire, January 1967).
  • Edward Higgins White (Apollo 1 fire, January 1967)
  • Roger B. Chaffee (Apollo 1 fire, January 1967)
  • Edward Givens (car accident, 1967)
  • Clifton Williams (plane accident, October 1967)
  • Michael James Adams (the only X-15 pilot killed during a X-15 test in November 1967. He was not a NASA astronaut).
  • Robert Henry Lawrence, Jr., planned to be an Air Force pilot, but he died in a plane crash in December 1967.
  • Thomas Ronald Baron (died with family in a car crash with train, 1967 after being fired for talking to Congress about the cause of the Apollo 1 fire). Ruled as suicide. Baron wrote a report critical of the Apollo program and was a critic after the Apollo 1 fire.[57][58]
  • Brian Welch, died a few months after debunking a Fox television show about the 'moon hoax'.[59]

All the deaths except for Irwin's were related to their job with NASA or the Air Force. Mike Adams and Robert Lawrence were not involved with the civilian space program. James Irwin already had several heart attacks before his death. All except two of the deaths happened at least one or two years before Apollo 11. Also, Brian Welch was speaking out against the moon hoax, so he would not have been a good target to be killed.

As of November 2018, four of the twelve Apollo astronauts who landed on the Moon between 1969 and 1972 were still alive, including Buzz Aldrin. Also, nine of the twelve Apollo astronauts who flew to the Moon without landing between 1968 and 1972 are still alive, for example Michael Collins.

During 1961 to 1972, at least eight Russian cosmonauts died:

Additionally, the chief of their spaceflight program, Sergei Korolev, died in January 1966.

Third-party information of Moon landings

Landing sites

 
A later LRO photo of the Apollo 14 landing site
 
Apollo 17 landing site

Conspiracy theorists say that telescopes, for example the Hubble, should be able to take pictures of the moon where Apollo landed, and if people really did land on the moon, then the pictures should show the scars on the moon's surface and equipment it left behind. They believe that our major observatories will not take pictures of the landing sites because it would expose the cover-up.

NASA has said that images have been taken of these landing sites, but the pictures taken by Hubble are too low quality to see very much detail.[60] In 2009 NASA released pictures from the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter showing the Apollo landing sites in more detail. These photographs have not convinced the conspiracy theorists because the pictures were taken by NASA, and they think NASA is behind the cover-up.[61]

Technology

Bart Sibrel (a conspiracy theorist) says that the Soviet Union had much more time in space than the United States before the Apollo Program. The Soviet Union put the first satellite in orbit in October 1957 named Sputnik 1.[Note 1] They also put the first animal in space in Sputnik 2, and were the first country to safely bring back an animal from space in Sputnik 5. Yuri Gagrin was the first man to orbit the Earth in Vostok 1, who was also from the Soviet Union. Sibrel believes that since the Soviet Union was so far ahead of the United States in the Moon race, the United States had to fake the landings to win.

On January 27, 1967, Apollo 1 caught fire and killed 3 astronauts. Two years later, NASA said that the problems which caused the fire were fixed. Bart Sibrel believes that the problems could not be fixed, so NASA decided to fake the landings to win the Moon race.

NASA says that the Soviet Union's achievements were not as impressive as the United States.[62] According to the Encyclopaedia Astronautica, the US spent 1,864 hours in space, while the Soviets spent 697 hours at the completion of Soyuz 5. Apollo 7 launched in October 1968, 21 months after the Apollo 1 fire, with an astronaut on board. By Apollo 11, the United States' lead was even bigger.

Both the United States and the Soviet Union had many problems during the Moon race. The Soviet Union had the first in-flight death in 1967, only 3 months after the Apollo 1 fire. According to NASA, most of the accomplishments first made by the Soviets were also made by the US within a year. By 1965, the US started to beat the Soviets to a few important steps. The Soviets had never developed a rocket which could land on the Moon, and they never tested landing on the Moon with an astronaut on board.[63]

Moon rocks

 
Genesis Rock brought back by Apollo 15 - older than any rocks on Earth

Some conspiracy theorists say that the Moon rocks collected by the Apollo Program are actually meteorites from Antarctica. Wernher von Braun, the Marshall Space Flight Center Director, and three others traveled to Antarctica in 1967 (three years before the Apollo launch) to explore for future space missions.[64] Some conspiracy theorists believe that Braun collected meteorites during this trip to use as fake moon rocks.

The Apollo Program collected 380 kilograms (840 pounds) of moon rocks during the Apollo 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, and 17 missions. According to scientists around the world, these rocks are very different from meteorites and other rocks found on Earth.[65] The rocks are also 200,000,000 (200 million) years older than any rock found on Earth, and are similar to moon rocks later brought back by the USSR.[66]

Some moon rocks could have been collected without landing on the moon, but the first moon rock was found on Earth in 1979, and it was only discovered in 1982 that it came from the moon.[67][68][69] Also, moon rocks are very rare on Earth, and only 30 kilograms (66 pounds) have ever been discovered, while the Apollo missions brought back 380 kilograms.[69]

Research

In 2004, Martin Hendry and Ken Skeldon from the University of Glasgow investigated the 'Moon Hoax'.[70] In November 2004, they spoke at the Glasgow Science Centre and examined the top ten lines of evidence that a hoax had taken place.[71]

Moon Landing Conspiracy Theories Media

  • The Apollo TV camera as it was mounted on the side of the Lunar Module

  • Lunar surface under the Lunar Module Eagle

  • Surveyor 3 with Apollo 12 lander in background

  • Photo of the degraded image after the SSTV scan conversion

  • Lunar Roving Vehicle flown on Apollo 15

  • Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter photo of Apollo 17 landing site (click to enlarge)

  • Apollo 11 landing site – "There the lunar module sits, parked just where it landed 40 years ago, as if it still really were 40 years ago and all the time since merely imaginary." –The New York Times

  • Apollo 17 LM leaving the Moon; rocket exhaust visible only briefly

  • Apollo 8 launch through the first stage separation

Related pages

Notes and references

Notes

  1. ↑ According to the 2007 NOVA episode "Sputnik Declassified", the United States could have launched the Explorer 1 probe before Sputnik, but the Eisenhower administration waited, first because they were not sure if international law meant that national borders kept going all the way into orbit (and, thus, their orbiting satellite could cause an international uproar by violating the borders of dozens of nations), and second because there was a desire to see the not yet ready Vanguard satellite program, designed by American citizens, become America's first satellite rather than the Explorer program, that was mostly designed by former rocket designers from Nazi Germany. A transcript of the appropriate section from the show is available at "A Blow to the Nation".

References

  1. ↑ Ralph René, "NASA mooned America[dead link]", 1994
  2. ↑ "33" «Скайлэб» - блестящий эпилог «Аполлона» ["Skylab" - the brilliant epilogue of "Apollo"] (in русский). 2010-04-15. Retrieved 2019-05-14.
  3. ↑ The wrong stuff Archived 2010-01-14 at the Wayback Machine, R. van Bakel, 9/94
  4. ↑ Getting Apollo 11 right, ABC, 7/99
  5. ↑ Lessons of the 'fake Moon flight' myth Archived 2010-05-29 at the Wayback Machine, J. Oberg, Skeptical Inquirer, 3–4/03, pp. 23, 30
  6. ↑ Apollo Truth, S. Colby, 2/3/09
  7. ↑ Obama's cancellation of Moon landings is a case of "No we can't", not "Yes we can" Archived 2011-05-15 at the Wayback Machine, T. Young, 2/2/10
  8. ↑ "Did We Go Moon". Archived from the original on 2021-04-20.
  9. ↑ "To Boldly Go Where We've All Gone Before". ISKCON News. https://iskconnews.org/to-boldly-go-where-weve-all-gone-before,1244/. 
  10. ↑ MoonShadows, J. Beals, 13/10/05
  11. ↑ 1961: Soviets win space race, BBC, 12/4/61
  12. ↑ Chronology of the Moon race, A. Zak, 16/2/09
  13. ↑ Bush unveils vision for Moon and beyond Archived 2010-02-09 at the Wayback Machine, CNN, 15/1/04
  14. ↑ Interview with Alexander Ivanovich Popovox, A. Gromov, 10/3/09 (Russ.)
  15. ↑ Obama has turned his back on the Moon, A. Borisov, 2/2/10
  16. ↑ Chaikin, Andrew (1998). A Man on the Moon: The Voyages of the Apollo Astronauts. Penguin Group USA. ISBN 978-0-14-027201-7.
  17. ↑ Apollo 11: On the Moon, Look, 8/69, p. 65
  18. ↑ J. Cranny, "Did man land on the Moon?", Johnson City, Texas, 1970
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 Did US astronauts really land on the Moon?[dead link], NASA, 6/77 (reissued 14/2/01)
  20. ↑ Bennett, Mary; Percy, David S. (2001). Dark Moon: Apollo and the Whistle-blowers. Adventures Unlimited Press. ISBN 978-0-932813-90-9.
  21. ↑ What happened on the Moon (2000), Aulis Publishers, 28/11/07
  22. ↑ Brian Welch, NASA Director of Media Services, dies Archived 2010-03-16 at the Wayback Machine, NASA, 27/11/00
  23. ↑ Bruce Nash, CEO/President Archived 2010-01-15 at the Wayback Machine, Nash Entertainment, 4/1/10
  24. ↑ Conspiracy theory: Did we land on the Moon? on IMDb
  25. ↑ Moonstruck, K. Soller, 17/7/09
  26. ↑ The great Moon hoax Archived 2009-12-17 at the Wayback Machine, T. Philips, 23/2/01
  27. ↑ "The Moon landing hoax". Archived from the original on January 21, 2008., G. Knier & B. Bray, 30/3/01
  28. ↑ Photographing stars Archived 2017-01-31 at the Wayback Machine, NASA, 26/5/09
  29. ↑ Did we really land on the Moon? Suggestions for science teachers, P. Lowman, 4/3/01
  30. ↑ Exhibits for loan from the Goddard Visitor Centre. Lunar and meteorite samples for loans Archived 2010-03-16 at the Wayback Machine, NASA, 10/3/09
  31. ↑ NASA pulls Moon hoax book, BBC, 8/11/02
  32. ↑ One giant hoax for mankind, BBC, 11/11/02
  33. ↑ One giant leap for conspiricists, M. Lawson, 9/11/02
  34. ↑ Hoaxers vs rocket scientists: Even NASA unsure how to counter claims of faked Moon missions Archived 2009-12-09 at the Wayback Machine, M. Dunn, 21/12/02
  35. ↑ The search for the Apollo 11 SSTV tapes Archived 2007-06-13 at the Wayback Machine, J. Sarkissian, 21/5/06, p. 15
  36. ↑ A brief history of the Apollo hoax, J. Daley, 30/9/08
  37. ↑ "Lost tapes" lost for good, NASA releases restored footage of first moonwalk, R. Pearlman, 17/7/09
  38. ↑ Moonwalk video gets a makeover Archived 2010-05-14 at the Wayback Machine, A. Boyle, 16/7/09
  39. ↑ Longuski 2006, p. 102
  40. ↑ Aaronovitch, David (2010). Voodoo Histories: The Role of the Conspiracy Theory in Shaping Modern History. Riverhead Books (Hardcover). pp. 1-2. ISBN 978-1-59448-895-5.
  41. ↑ Ian Goddard (2001-02-26). "Apollo Moon Photos: a Hoax?". Retrieved 2019-05-14.
  42. ↑ Jay Windley. "Clavius: Photography – crosshairs". Moon Base Clavius. Clavius.org. Retrieved April 20, 2013.
  43. ↑ Jay Windley. "Clavius: Photo Analysis – lunar rover". Moon Base Clavius. Clavius.org. Retrieved September 5, 2009.
  44. ↑ Alan Shepard; Deke Slayton (1994). Moon Shot: The Inside Story of America's Race to the Moon. With Jay Barbree and Howard Benedict; introduction by Neil Armstrong. Atlanta: Turner Publishing. ISBN 978-1-878685-54-4.
  45. ↑ Phillips, Tony (January 27, 2005). "Sickening Solar Flares". Science@NASA. NASA. Archived from the original on June 15, 2011. Retrieved November 25, 2008.
  46. ↑ Cull, Selby (July 12, 2006). "Predicting Solar Eruptions". News from Sky & Telescope (Sky Publishing). http://www.skyandtelescope.com/news/3422566.html?page=1&c=y. Retrieved November 25, 2008. 
  47. ↑ missing blueprints
  48. ↑ blueprints not saved
  49. ↑ "Did We Go? The Evidence Is In!". Moonhoax.com. Retrieved November 25, 2008.
  50. ↑ "On Eagle's Wing: The Story of the Parkes Apollo 11 Support". Parkes.atnf.csiro.au. Retrieved November 25, 2008.
  51. ↑ Amalfi, Carmelo (November 1, 2006). "Lost Moon landing tapes discovered". Cosmos Online (Cosmos Magazine). http://www.cosmosmagazine.com/node/818. Retrieved November 25, 2008. 
  52. ↑ "Search for SSTV tapes" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on July 5, 2008. Retrieved September 5, 2009.
  53. ↑ "The GSFC Scientific Data Storage Problem" (PDF). NASA. Retrieved September 5, 2009.
  54. ↑ NASA final report on the missing Apollo 11 telemetry tapes (large PDF) commons.wikimedia.org
  55. ↑ Borenstein, Seth (July 16, 2009). NASA lost moon footage, but Hollywood restores it. https://www.usnews.com/articles/science/2009/07/17/nasa-lost-moon-footage-but-hollywood-restores-it.html. Retrieved September 5, 2009. 
  56. ↑ Garner, Robert (August 7, 2009). "Apollo 11 Partial Restoration HD Video Streams". NASA. Archived from the original on September 3, 2009. Retrieved September 5, 2009.
  57. ↑ "Comments on the FOX special on the Hoax". Pirlwww.lpl.arizona.edu. Retrieved November 25, 2008.
  58. ↑ "NASA Apollo Mission Apollo-1- Baron Report". History.nasa.gov. Retrieved November 25, 2008.
  59. ↑ Oberg, James. "Lessons of the 'Fake Moon Flight' Myth," Skeptical Inquirer, March/April 2003, pp. 23, 30. Reprinted in Frazier, Kendrick (ed.) (2009). Science Under Siege. Prometheus Books. ISBN 978-1-59102-715-7
  60. ↑ "Hubble Shoots The Moon". NASA. Archived from the original on December 4, 2010. Retrieved October 20, 2009.
  61. ↑ Kelly, A (September 10, 2009). "A Hoax Believer Response to the LRO Photographs". LunarLandingHoax.com. Archived from the original on October 18, 2009. Retrieved September 10, 2009.
  62. ↑ Jay Windley. "Clavius: Technology - beating the soviets". Clavius.org. Retrieved September 5, 2009.
  63. ↑ "Soviet Lunar Landing". Encyclopaedia Astronautica. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
  64. ↑ "Marshall Highlights for 1967". Marshall Space Flight Center History Office. Archived from the original on 2014-08-04. Retrieved 2010-04-27.
  65. ↑ Phillips, Tony. "The Great Moon Hoax: Moon rocks and common sense prove Apollo astronauts really did visit the Moon". Science@NASA. Archived from the original on 2009-12-17. Retrieved 2010-04-27.
  66. ↑ Papike, James; Ryder, Graham; Shearer, Charles (1998). "Lunar Samples". Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry. 36: 5.1–5.234.
  67. ↑ Head, James N; Melosh, H. Jay; Ivanov, Boris A (2002). "High-speed ejecta from small craters". Science. 298 (5599): 1752–1756. doi:10.1126/science.1077483. PMID 12424385. S2CID 2969674.
  68. ↑ Cooke, Bill (2006). "The Great Interplanetary Rock Swap". Astronomy Magazine. 34 (8): 64–67. Bibcode:2006Ast....34h..64C. ISSN 0091-6358.
  69. ↑ 69.0 69.1 Korotev, Randy (2005). "Lunar geochemistry as told by lunar meteorites". Chemie der Erde. 65 (4): 297–346. Bibcode:2005ChEG...65..297K. doi:10.1016/j.chemer.2005.07.001.
  70. ↑ Hendry, Martin; Skeldon, Ken (February 17, 2005). "Did we really land on the Moon?". Cafescientifique.org. Archived from the original on August 5, 2009. Retrieved August 26, 2009.
  71. ↑ Di Maggio, Mario (November 2004). "Hoax Busters". Dimaggio.org. Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved August 26, 2009.

Other websites

Template:Pseudoscience

Retrieved from "https://wiki.kidzsearch.com/w/index.php?title=Moon_landing_conspiracy_theories&oldid=5739283"